< Return to PAMED Newsroom

Supreme Court Rules Unfavorably on Risk of Harm in PAMED/AMA Amicus Case

Last Updated

Nov 4, 2026, 09:07 AM

On October 29, 2026, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled unfavorably in a case in which PAMED and the AMA had partnered on an amici curiae brief. The case, Smith v. Kannarkatt, et al., was a medical malpractice action where the appeal concerned the legal proof necessary to get an increased risk of harm case to the jury. The Supreme Court affirmed the Superior Court’s ruling that the plaintiff had presented sufficient evidence at trial to send the case to the jury for a determination of liability.

As background, the estate of Tanya Smith sued Smith’s treating oncologist, and the treatment facility based on increased risk of harm after another physician had misdiagnosed Tanya Smith’s cancer as breast cancer, when it was, in fact, a rare form of lymphoma. Tanya Smith subsequently died from cancer.

Tanya Smith’s estate received a financial recovery from the physician who made the misdiagnosis. The estate then brought this action against the treating physician, Dr. Annie Kannarkatt, and Cancer Care Associates of York, the facility where Dr. Kannarkatt provided treatment. Two trials were conducted in county court in this case. The first ended with a hung jury. The judge dismissed the second prior to the case going to the jury, ruling that the plaintiff had failed to make out a case.

On appeal, the Superior Court ruled that the county court had erroneously applied the applicable legal standard in dismissing the case and ordered a new trial. The Superior Court found that plaintiff’s expert witness had presented sufficient evidence to establish a case that defendant Dr. Kannarkatt’s failure to question the other involved physicians in light of conflicting clinical and radiological findings increased the risk of harm to Tanya Smith sufficiently to require the case be decided by the jury. Dr. Kannarkatt and Cancer Care Associates of York appealed to the Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court ruled that the expert opinion constituted sufficient evidence to overcome the motion for a nonsuit and send the case to the jury. The expert had opined that the delay in a correct diagnosis due to Dr. Kannarkatt’s failure to consult the other physicians increased the risk of harm to Smith, undermined Smith’s ability to fight off the cancer and shortened Smith’s lifespan. The case now moves back to York County for a third trial.

Load more comments
Login to be able to comment
PAMED ProAssurance